This weekend, the 98th Academy Awards will honor the best films of the year, but it is also interesting to reflect on the masterpieces that have marked the last fifteen years. In this article, we will review the films awarded the Oscar for Best Picture, assessing their relevance and impact on cinema yesterday and today.
Green Book: On the Roads of the South (2019)
This film won an Oscar that sparked much controversy. Although it was awarded three statues, including that of Best Picture, Green Book has often been criticized for its simplistic and overly refined approach to racial relations. Several observers saw it as a regression, particularly compared to Moonlight, which tackled the same subject with much deeper substance.
The King’s Speech (2011)
The biopic about King George VI, which won four Oscars, including Best Picture, is a film intended to be inspirational. However, Tom Hooper’s work has been considered by many as a conventional melodrama, tailor-made to appeal to Academy voters. Although technically well-made, The King’s Speech is rarely revisited, making way for more innovative works from its time.
CODA (2022)
By becoming the first film released by a streamer to win the Oscar for Best Picture, CODA made headlines with its heartfelt portrayal of a family. However, its victory has not completely withstood the test of time, and it seems to have already faded from memory. This is regrettable, as despite its sentimental nature, the film offered a touching sincerity and emotional depth.
The Artist (2012)
Winning five Oscars, The Artist certainly marked its era with its homage to the silent film era. While it has charm, with a nostalgic tone and style, its victory is often questioned, being perceived as the best of a group of mediocre works. This film raises questions about the selection criteria of the Academy.
Spotlight (2016)
Recognized with two Oscars, including Best Picture, Spotlight is a tribute to investigative journalism. Although it addresses dark topics of abuse, the film may seem too conventional compared to bolder works. Its victory has sparked debates about the Academy’s cautious choices.
Argo (2013)
With three Oscars to its name, Argo is a film that blends suspense and drama. Despite its popularity, the film has faced criticism for its sometimes simplistic approach to real events. This raises questions about the importance given to historical authenticity in reward reciprocity.
Birdman (2015)
The film by Alejandro González Iñárritu won four Oscars, notably for its technical innovation. While it has garnered admiration, it faces criticism regarding its emotional depth compared to other films. This raises the question of whether artistic complexity always equates to merit at the Oscars.
Nomadland (2021)
With three Oscars, including Best Director, Nomadland sought to present an empathetic view of contemporary struggles. Although it was well received, it failed to achieve lasting success post-Oscars, demonstrating the volatility of the film world.
The Shape of Water (2018)
An homage to old cinema, The Shape of Water by Guillermo Del Toro also won four Oscars. However, some believe that other films of its time, such as Phantom Thread, deserved more recognition. This clever choice highlights the subjectivity of academic votes.
Oppenheimer (2024)
This biopic managed to capture the complex essence of a historical figure while engaging the audience. With seven Oscars, it made a sensation. However, like other acclaimed films, it can be questioned regarding its female roles and the representation that accompanies it.
Everything Everywhere All At Once (2023)
The victory of this film, which won seven Oscars, represents a pivotal moment in Oscar history. By diverging from usual conventions, it combines diversity, boldness, and reflection on universal themes. The surprise of its success is both exhilarating and revealing of the ongoing changes in Hollywood.
Anora (2025)
The film by Sean Baker has managed to capture attention with its bold vision, winning five Oscars. The connection between the themes of love, class, and relationships is an interesting exploration. Its unexpected victory shows that the Academy is open to new voices.
Twelve Years a Slave (2014)
Twelve Years A Slave is undoubtedly one of the most significant films of its time, winning three Oscars for its poignant representation of slavery in the United States. Its emotional and social impact has cemented its status as a masterpiece.
Moonlight (2017)
This film made headlines not only for its powerful narrative on identity but also for one of the most memorable moments in Oscar history with the announcement mistake. Rightfully, it won three Oscars, leaving a lasting legacy.
Parasite (2020)
Bong Joon-ho’s direction was a revelation, blurring the boundaries between international cinema and the Hollywood landscape. Winning four Oscars, Parasite broke stereotypes and introduced a foreign language film as a Best Picture winner. Its audacity and depth make it a true masterpiece.
